An octopus remembers where it experienced pain and actively seeks relief. Bees appear to play for enjoyment, while tiny fruit flies show sleeping patterns that resemble those found in humans. These discoveries are changing how scientists think about the minds of animals.
For decades, animal consciousness was largely discussed in relation to mammals and birds. However, a growing body of research suggests that fish, reptiles, crustaceans, and even insects could have subjective experiences. Now, an international group of scientists is urging the world to take these findings seriously.
Scientists Are Challenging Long-Held Beliefs About Animal Consciousness
For a long time, humans have viewed consciousness through the lens of their own experiences. Animals that display recognizable intelligence, emotional behavior, and social connections have often received more attention than creatures with very different nervous systems. However, researchers are discovering that the ability to experience the world could be much more widespread than previously assumed.
On April 19, 2024, an international group of scientists and philosophers introduced the New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness. Around 40 experts initially signed the declaration, recognizing the growing scientific evidence that numerous animal species could possess conscious experiences. Their work brought renewed attention to research involving mammals, birds, fish, reptiles, octopuses, crabs, and insects.
The declaration states: “There is strong scientific support for the view that mammals and birds have conscious experiences.” It also recognizes a realistic possibility of consciousness in other vertebrates, including reptiles, amphibians, and fish, alongside several groups of invertebrates.
The distinction is particularly important because consciousness involves more than simply detecting something in the environment. Scientists are investigating whether animals can experience sensations and feelings, including pleasure, pain, fear, and other subjective states. Researchers often describe this capacity as phenomenal consciousness, also known as sentience.
Philosopher Thomas Nagel famously explored the question of subjective experience by asking what it is like to be a bat. His question captures the difficulty researchers face when attempting to understand another creature’s inner experience. An animal cannot explain what it feels, leaving scientists to investigate its behavior and neurological activity.
Octopuses May Remember Pain And Actively Seek Relief

One of the most striking examples of possible animal consciousness comes from research involving octopuses. These marine animals are already known for their problem-solving abilities and unusual intelligence. However, experiments suggest that their responses to painful experiences could reveal something beyond sophisticated behavior.
In a 2021 study, cephalopod researcher Robyn Crook investigated whether octopuses responded to pain in ways that suggested conscious suffering. The experiment used a method called the conditioned place preference test, which was originally developed to assess pain in laboratory rats.
Researchers first allowed octopuses to choose between two chambers inside a tank. Some animals then received an injection of acetic acid while inside their preferred chamber, producing a painful stimulus. Following the experience, these octopuses developed a lasting aversion to the chamber where they had received the injection.
The researchers then introduced a local anesthetic called lidocaine while the animals were inside the chamber they had initially disliked. The octopuses subsequently developed a preference for that location, suggesting they associated it with relief from the earlier painful experience.
This result attracted attention because the animals appeared to remember where they experienced pain and where they experienced relief. Similar behavior in humans or other mammals would normally be interpreted as evidence of a painful experience followed by effective relief.
The findings therefore provide an important reason to investigate octopus welfare more carefully. They also raise questions about practices such as octopus farming, where the possibility of conscious suffering deserves serious consideration.
Bees Appear To Play For Enjoyment Without Receiving Rewards

Bees are generally associated with pollination, honey production, and their complex social structures. However, research published in 2022 revealed a behavior that surprised scientists studying animal cognition. Bumblebees were observed rolling small wooden balls around without any obvious practical purpose.
The researchers identified several characteristics suggesting that the activity resembled play. The bees appeared to engage in the behavior voluntarily, and the activity did not seem necessary for obtaining food or achieving another immediate goal.
Their observations included several features associated with play:
- Repeated activity: Bumblebees rolled the wooden balls repeatedly, suggesting that they voluntarily returned to the activity.
- No obvious practical purpose: The behavior did not appear to help the insects find food or complete another essential task.
- Variation in movements: The bees did not roll the balls in exactly the same way each time, suggesting flexibility in their behavior.
- Relaxed conditions: Ball rolling increased when the bees were relaxed, rather than appearing primarily during stressful situations.
- Intrinsic motivation: The activity seemed rewarding in itself instead of functioning as a means to achieve another outcome.
Play is frequently associated with positive emotional experiences in animals. Although the experiment cannot establish precisely what a bee feels, the findings suggest that insects may experience rewarding states that scientists have historically overlooked.
Researchers have traditionally concentrated heavily on identifying signs of animal pain and suffering. The bee experiment encourages a broader investigation into whether other creatures also experience positive states such as enjoyment.
Crows Can Report What They See Through Their Behavior

Crows have developed a reputation for their remarkable intelligence, and experiments suggest their cognitive abilities could be more sophisticated than many people realize. A 2020 study published in Science investigated whether these birds could communicate information about their own visual experiences.
Researchers trained crows to report whether they had seen a visual stimulus. The birds used head movements to indicate whether they had been shown a bright stimulus, a dim stimulus, or nothing at all. They generally reported their perceptions accurately, although mistakes became more common when the stimulus was particularly dim.
Scientists also monitored activity in a brain region called the nidopallium caudolaterale, or NCL. This region is associated with higher-level cognition in birds and is considered relevant to research into their perceptual abilities.
The researchers discovered that neural activity in this region tracked whether the crows reported seeing a stimulus rather than simply whether a stimulus had been presented. This suggested that the brain activity could be associated with the birds’ visual experiences.
The experiment offered another important piece of evidence in the investigation of animal consciousness. It also demonstrated how researchers can study possible subjective experiences without relying on animals communicating through human language.
Fish And Snakes Display Unexpected Signs Of Self-Recognition

Self-awareness has traditionally been investigated using the mirror-mark test. During this experiment, researchers observe whether an animal recognizes its reflection and attempts to remove a mark placed on its own body after seeing it in a mirror.
Cleaner wrasse fish have produced particularly interesting results in this area. Between 2019 and 2023, researchers conducted experiments examining how these fish responded to their reflections.
Initially, the fish behaved aggressively toward the mirror, apparently treating their reflections as rivals. Their behavior eventually changed as they began performing unusual movements in front of the mirror, including swimming upside down. Researchers also observed behavior suggesting that the fish were examining their reflections.
When scientists placed a colored mark on the fish, the animals attempted to remove it by scraping against an available surface after seeing the mark in the mirror. These observations suggested that cleaner wrasse could pass important stages of the mirror-mark test.
Garter Snakes Recognize Changes In Their Own Scent

Snakes have attracted attention through a different approach to self-recognition. Because these animals rely heavily on chemical signals, researchers questioned whether a visual test could adequately examine their awareness of themselves.
A 2024 study investigated whether garter snakes could recognize their individual scent. Researchers presented cotton pads containing different combinations of familiar and unfamiliar scents, including the snakes’ own scent with an additional scent acting as a mark.
The garter snakes investigated their own marked scents for longer than the other samples. This suggested that they recognized their individual scent and noticed when it had changed.
The research raises an interesting question about how scientists define self-recognition. An experiment designed around human vision could overlook abilities that other animals experience through smell or entirely different sensory systems.
Fruit Flies Have Surprisingly Complex Sleeping Patterns

Fruit flies are among the smallest creatures included in recent consciousness research. Despite their size, scientists have discovered surprisingly complicated patterns in their sleeping behavior.
Researchers have identified two distinct types of sleep in fruit flies: quiet sleep and active sleep. Quiet sleep involves significantly reduced brain activity, while active sleep involves continued brain activity despite an absence of outward behavior.
Scientists believe these different patterns may serve separate functions. Quiet sleep appears connected to metabolic regulation and stress, while active sleep may support cognitive processes. Researchers have compared the distinction with different stages of human sleep, although the precise similarities remain under investigation.
Another study published in Nature in 2021 discovered that social isolation disrupts sleep in fruit flies. The flies slept best when other flies were present, while their sleeping patterns changed when they were separated from their companions.
These findings have attracted attention because sleep is closely connected to brain function in humans and many other animals. Scientists are still investigating what these patterns reveal about insect experiences, but the research adds another reason to reconsider assumptions about the mental lives of very small creatures.
Crabs And Crayfish Also Display Signs Of Complex Experiences

Crustaceans have traditionally received relatively little attention in discussions about animal consciousness. However, experiments involving crabs and crayfish have uncovered behavior that researchers believe deserves closer examination.
A 2024 study investigated how shore crabs balance competing motivations when faced with uncomfortable situations. Researchers examined how the animals responded to bright light and electric shocks, two conditions that could influence their decisions about entering shelters.
Normally, shore crabs prefer entering shelters to escape bright light. However, when they experienced an electric shock inside a particular shelter, their behavior changed. They sometimes chose to remain in bright conditions rather than return to the location associated with the unpleasant experience.
Their decisions also depended on the intensity of the shock and the brightness of the surrounding environment. This suggested that the crabs could weigh competing needs rather than responding through a simple automatic reaction.
Earlier research between 2014 and 2017 also investigated anxiety-like states in crayfish. Scientists placed the animals in mazes containing bright and dark pathways, observing how their behavior changed after exposure to stressful electrical shocks.
The stressed crayfish became more reluctant to explore brightly lit areas. However, animals given benzodiazepines, a class of drugs used to alleviate anxiety in humans, became more willing to explore those areas again.
Researchers described these responses as anxiety-like states. Although the findings do not establish that crayfish experience anxiety exactly as humans do, they provide additional evidence that their behavioral responses deserve scientific attention.
Scientists Disagree About Whether The Evidence Is Conclusive

Despite the growing number of discoveries, scientists have not reached complete agreement about animal consciousness. One major challenge is that consciousness cannot currently be measured directly in another living creature, leaving researchers to interpret behavior, brain activity, memory, and responses to different experiences.
An animal avoiding a particular location could indicate a painful memory. However, scientists must also consider whether the behavior could occur through unconscious processing. Demonstrating intelligence or problem-solving ability does not automatically establish that an animal has subjective experiences.
Hakwan Lau, a researcher at Japan’s RIKEN Center for Brain Science, expressed skepticism about the available evidence. “I don’t think any decisive evidence has emerged so far,” Lau commented, emphasizing the importance of distinguishing between conscious and unconscious perception.
His position reflects an important scientific debate about how researchers should interpret animal behavior. Even when an experiment produces surprising results, scientists must consider alternative explanations before reaching conclusions.
However, researchers supporting the New York Declaration argue that multiple lines of evidence deserve serious consideration. The declaration does not claim that every animal has been scientifically proven conscious. Instead, it recognizes that the available evidence makes consciousness a realistic possibility across a much wider range of species.
The New Declaration Could Change How Humans Treat Animals

The New York Declaration makes an important distinction between scientific certainty and ethical responsibility. Its signatories recognize strong scientific support for consciousness in mammals and birds, alongside a realistic possibility of consciousness in other vertebrates and many invertebrates.
The declaration argues that this possibility deserves consideration when decisions affect animal welfare. Researchers believe that waiting for absolute certainty could mean overlooking serious risks to creatures that may already be capable of suffering.
Invertebrates deserve particular attention because they represent an enormous proportion of animal life. Many are used in food production and scientific research, while even larger numbers live in natural environments where they face disease, starvation, parasitism, and predation.
The declaration also raises questions about the future. If humans eventually establish settlements on other planets, they could unintentionally introduce insects and other small creatures into unfamiliar environments. Their welfare would deserve consideration under the same principles.
The possibility of conscious artificial intelligence also enters the discussion. If future technologies produce systems capable of subjective experiences, researchers may need to consider their welfare regardless of whether those experiences arise from biological or artificial systems.
The declaration does not prescribe a particular policy or demand that every animal receive identical treatment. Its central message is that realistic possibilities of consciousness should be taken seriously when making decisions that could cause suffering.
Animal Consciousness Research Has Reached An Important Turning Point
The New York Declaration builds on decades of research, including the 2012 Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness. That earlier statement recognized strong evidence for consciousness in many nonhuman animals and specifically discussed neurological evidence involving several invertebrate groups.
The newer declaration reflects how much scientific understanding has developed over the past decade. Researchers now have additional evidence involving memory, self-recognition, play, sleep, pain avoidance, and flexible decision-making across a surprisingly diverse range of species.
There is still plenty scientists do not understand about animal consciousness. However, the possibility that an octopus can suffer, a bee can experience something resembling play, or a crab can remember an unpleasant experience deserves careful investigation.
Humans have spent centuries deciding which animals deserve attention based largely on how closely they resemble us. Science is now raising a difficult question about that approach: if a creature can experience pain, does its size or species really change how seriously its suffering should be considered?

