Antiques Roadshow guest refuses to believe value – leaving expert ‘on the floor’

An Antiques Roadshow expert was left stunned when a guest refused to believe the valuation given for a brooch they brought onto the show. In the recent episode, a mother and daughter presented jewellery specialist Joanna Hardy with a ballerina-shaped brooch that had been gifted to the mother by a Polish jeweller bridge partner in the 1970s and 1980s. The guest was sceptical of the expert’s valuation, expressing doubts that it could be worth a substantial amount, even when the show was at Beaumaris Castle in Wales.

The brooch, adorned with turquoise, rubies, 18-carat gold and diamonds, was examined by Joanna Hardy, who noted its exquisite craftsmanship and resemblance to pieces by renowned jewellers Van Cleef and Arpels. However, the absence of a definitive signature on the brooch meant that only the company itself could verify its origins. Despite this uncertainty, Joanna estimated that if authenticated, the brooch could be valued at tens of thousands of pounds.

The guest, while taken aback by the potential worth, remained unconvinced, stating, “Can’t be.” Joanna encouraged them to seek verification from the jewellery company to confirm its authenticity. She praised the brooch as a “serious jewel” and emphasized its stunning design regardless of its final valuation.

The brooch’s association with Van Cleef and Arpels, known for their elegant ballerina brooches, added to its allure, sparking excitement among both the guest and the expert. Joanna expressed her fascination with the piece, highlighting its beauty and craftsmanship. Despite the uncertainty surrounding its provenance, the brooch remained a standout item on the show.

The Antiques Roadshow episode showcased not only the intricate details of the brooch but also the emotional connection it held for the guest and her family. The ongoing quest to uncover the true value of the piece added a compelling narrative to the episode, leaving viewers intrigued by the brooch’s potential worth and historical significance.

In conclusion, the Antiques Roadshow continues to capture the fascination of audiences with its blend of valuable insights, touching stories, and unexpected discoveries. The memorable moments, like the brooch valuation mystery, serve as a reminder of the enduring appeal of antiques and the thrill of uncovering hidden treasures in unexpected places.