Your cart is currently empty!
Mhairi Black claims the SNP government ‘made an arse’ of delivering policies

Former SNP MP Mhairi Black has openly criticized the Scottish Government for their mishandling of policies, referring to it as making a mess of things. Black, who made history as the youngest MP since 1832 when she won the Paisley seat in 2015 at the age of 20, stepped down at the last general election. In a recent podcast interview, she expressed her disappointment with the government’s ability to implement policies effectively, stating that the Scottish Parliament lacks the power to significantly impact people’s lives.
During the podcast, Black also shared her opinions on key figures within the SNP, describing former First Minister Alex Salmond as a “charlatan” for his involvement in setting up the Alba party. She highlighted her belief that John Swinney, the Deputy First Minister, leans economically towards the right wing. Black indicated that she does not see herself pursuing a career as an MSP, as she anticipates disagreements with the SNP’s policies and values.
Black further critiqued the leadership within the SNP, categorizing Nicola Sturgeon and Humza Yousaf as left-of-centre leaders, while suggesting that Swinney’s economic beliefs are more right-leaning. She expressed concerns about the internal dynamics of the party, suggesting that without a unifying goal like independence, the SNP could fracture.
Reflecting on her views on the SNP’s current state, Black touched upon the “trans issue” within the party and the resurgence of social conservatism, which she believes had been suppressed during Sturgeon’s leadership. She emphasized the importance of Westminster in effecting substantial societal change, indicating her preference for focusing on national politics rather than Scottish Parliament affairs.
In light of the recent controversies surrounding Salmond, including allegations of sexual harassment, Black expressed her shock at the extent of fear and intimidation that surrounded the former First Minister. She criticised the appointment of Peter Murrell, Sturgeon’s ex-husband, as the SNP’s chief executive, highlighting concerns about conflicts of interest and ethical considerations within the party.
As Black voiced her criticisms and insights, she highlighted deeper issues within the SNP and the challenges faced by the party in maintaining unity and coherence amidst internal disagreements and external pressures.
**Insights and Summary:**
Mhairi Black’s candid remarks provide a rare insider perspective on the challenges and divisions within the SNP. Her criticisms of the Scottish Government’s policy delivery and the leadership dynamics shed light on underlying issues that may impact the party’s cohesion. The intersection of personal convictions, political strategies, and party dynamics highlighted in Black’s comments reflects broader challenges faced by political entities navigating complex issues and power structures. Black’s decision to step back from pursuing a role as an MSP underscores the complexities and considerations that individuals face when engaging in party politics and advocating for meaningful change.