Two Scots sailors died after tugboat capsized in 10 seconds due to safety system ‘breakdown’

Two Scottish sailors tragically lost their lives as a tugboat capsized in just 10 seconds on the River Clyde due to a breakdown in safety systems, according to a report. The incident occurred on February 24, 2023, when the tugboat Biter, operated by Clyde Marine Services, overturned while escorting a cruise ship into Greenock harbour. George Taft, 65, and Ian Catterson, 73, were onboard the tugboat and sadly did not survive the accident. Efforts to rescue them were hindered as the vessel quickly sank beneath the water. The bodies of the sailors were recovered 24 hours later.

An investigation by the Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) revealed several factors contributing to the tragic incident. The report highlighted that the training of the marine pilot did not adequately prepare them for working with conventional tugs. Incomplete exchanges between the pilot and the tugboat masters and cruise ship crew were also noted. The report emphasized the high speed of the cruise ship, which placed a significant load on the tugboat’s lines, affecting its stability and leading to the capsizing. Additionally, an open hatch compromised the tugboat’s watertight integrity, reducing the crew’s chances of survival.

Andrew Moll OBE, Chief Inspector of Marine Accidents, commented on the incident, stressing the importance of understanding and mitigating the vulnerabilities of conventional tugs in port operations. He highlighted the need for proper training, coordination, and monitoring to ensure the safety of all involved. The MAIB made recommendations for Clyde Marine Services Limited to review its safety management system and risk assessments, and for Clydeport Operations Limited to assess its marine pilot training and operations.

The tragic loss of George Taft and Ian Catterson serves as a poignant reminder of the critical importance of robust safety measures and effective communication in maritime operations. The swift and devastating capsizing of the tugboat Biter underscores the need for continual vigilance and adherence to safety protocols to prevent similar accidents in the future.

Insights:
Maritime accidents such as the capsizing of the tugboat Biter on the River Clyde highlight the inherent risks faced by seafarers in their line of work. The importance of comprehensive training, effective communication between crew members, and adherence to safety protocols cannot be overstated in preventing such tragic incidents. The recommendations put forth by the MAIB serve as valuable lessons for maritime companies and authorities to enhance safety measures and minimise risks in port operations. The loss of George Taft and Ian Catterson underscores the human toll of maritime accidents and underscores the need for a collective commitment to prioritising safety in all maritime activities.