Can A Cardinal Be Half Male Half Female? Birds Advice
Have you ever watched any strange cardinal? It might be a yellow cardinal, a leucistic white-red cardinal, or a cardinal that combines both male and female colors. Jeffrey and Shirley Caldwell in Pennsylvania spotted a weird cardinal that looks both half male and half female.
Now, the question is, can a cardinal be half male half female? The short answer is yes. A cardinal can be both male and female. According to BBC News, retired ornithologist Jamie Hill spotted and photographed a unique cardinal he had ever seen. Half of the cardinal body was tan, while the other part was bright red. The colors were split lengthwise down the middle, looking like two cardinals had been merged.
Sounds strange? But, it’s possible. Let’s explain how a dual-gendered cardinal is born. Here is another useful article for you: “Can cardinal birds be pets?” Check it out right now or keep reading the current article until the end.
What Does A Half-Male, Half-Female Cardinal Look Like?
A half-male, half-female cardinal looks to be bright red with a black face mask on one side and pale brown or subdued tan on the other side. The colors are divided lengthwise down the middle of the cardinal.
Biologically, a dual-gendered cardinal is, most of the time, male on its right side and female on its left side. The wings look mostly red. That’s why a half-male, half-female cardinal looks reddish throughout the back when it perches on a tree branch.
What Is A Half-Male, Half-Female Cardinal Called?
Half-male, half-female cardinals are called bilateral gynandromorphs, also known as ‘halfsiders’ among ornithologists. The interesting fact is many other birds, chickens, and insects can be gynandromorphs; however, they’re not easily recognized.
Among cardinals, there is sexual dimorphism—their males have iconic bright red plumage, while the females are pale brown or tan. Thanks to these aesthetic differences between male and female cardinals, identifying a gynandromorph cardinal is much easier.
How Does A Bird End Up Being Dual-Gendered?
According to experts, determining sex in birds is slightly different than in humans. In human beings like you and us, the male cells have one X and one Y chromosome, while the female cells carry 2 large, gene-rich X chromosomes.
Similar to humans, birds have sex chromosomes, but they’re the opposite. The sex chromosomes of birds are called Z and W. In this case, the female cells have one Z and one W chromosome, while the male cells have 2 Z chromosomes.
When it comes to cell mutation in birds, a nucleus of sex cells carries 2 chromosomes—one from the male and another from the female. The male sperm carries only a Z chromosome, while the female produces either Z or W carrying eggs.
If a female egg cell develops 2 nuclei, one with a W and one with a Z, and two Z-carrying sperm fertilizes them, then a gynandromorph is formed. After that, the gynandromorph develops half of its body as a female ZW and the other half as a male ZZ.
Rare Half-Male Half-Female Cardinal Spotted In Pennsylvania
Retired ornithologist Jamie Hill, an enthusiast birder for over 48 years, reported a rare half-male, half-female northern cardinal spotted in PA. He shared the experience on Facebook on 21 February 2021 and entitled it a “once-in-a-lifetime, one-in-a-million encounter.”
Hill knew about the cardinal from a friend who had spotted an ‘unusual bird’ coming to her feeders. Hill wondered whether the cardinal was albino or leucistic, meaning the specimen wouldn’t have enough pigmentation in its feathers.
However, once Jamie Hill sees the cardinal’s pictures on the friend’s cellphone, he determined it was a bilateral gynandromorph. He asked for permission to photograph the bird by visiting the home where the rare specimen had been snapped.
Mr. Hill stayed the home for one hour. During this period, the dual-gendered cardinal visited the feeders only once. However, it thankfully perched on tree branches for a while. That’s why he was finally able to photograph the rare cardinal nearly 50 times.
Here are some images of the rare cardinal:
Earlier in 2019, a couple of avid birdwatchers, Jeffrey and Shirley Caldwell spotted another half male, half female cardinal in a backyard in Erie, Pennsylvania. Once in a day, Shirley Caldwell looked out her kitchen window. She noticed an ‘unusual bird’ in the dawn redwood tree.
That was a northern cardinal with astounding colors. When the cardinal faced one direction, it looked like a male with signature scarlet plumage. But, when it faced the opposite, it looked like a female with subdued tan and pale brown feathers.
However, when the cardinal faced straight, it was half red and half brown, and both colors are divided lengthwise down the middle, looking like someone stitched a male and a female cardinal into one bird. It was a rare gynandromorph cardinal hoax.
As soon as Shirley Caldwell saw the weird cardinal, she took a few images of the bird and shared them with her bird lover friends and colleagues. National Geographic Featured the story, and it went viral around the world. She posted the photos on Facebook on 27 January 2019.
This happily married couple has been attracting a wide variety of birds for over 25 years with bird feeders to their backyard. But, they have never seen such a wonderful bird in their lifetime. They were not sure they saw the rare cardinal until the bird came closer to them.
What Did Top Media Caption This Once-In-A-Lifetime Moment?
- BBC News– “Rare bird: Half-male, half-female cardinal snapped in Pennsylvania.”
- Forbes – “Bizarre Half-Male, Half-Female Bird Discovered In Pennsylvania.”
- National Geographic – “Rare half-male, half-female cardinal spotted in Pennsylvania.”
- NBC News – “A cardinal that is half male, half female puzzles scientists, delights birdwatchers.”
- New York Times – “A Rare Bird Indeed: A Cardinal That’s Half Male, Half Female.”
- USA Today – “Pennsylvania man snaps a picture of rare half-male, half-female cardinal.”
Rare Half-Male Half-Female Cardinal Observed In Illinois
A rare cardinal with the male’s bright red plumage on its left side and the female’s brownish-grey feathers on its right side appeared in Rock Island, Illinois. This bird was the opposite of Jeffrey and Shirley Caldwell’s cardinal.
A retired high-school biology teacher was able to attract the dual-gendered cardinal to his backyard bird feeder. In December 2008, Brian Peer, a professor of biology at Western Illinois University with his colleague Robert Motz began studying the rare bird.
For the next two years, Prof. Peer visited the backyard of the teacher more than 40 times to study how the rare cardinal interacted with other birds and responded to calls. Unfortunately, he never saw the bird to be paired with others and singing.
Depending on Prof. Peer’s observations, the gynandromorphy cardinal is infertile, though Caldwells’ cardinal appears to be paired with another male cardinal. The gynandromorph wasn’t seen again because a male cardinal aggressively pushed out it from its territory.
According to Prof. Peer, half of the brain of the gynandromorph cardinal is male and another half is female. Biologically, the bird is itself a brother or a sister of the opposite side. These observations range from December 2008 to March 2010, nearly 2 years.
Professor Brian Peer and his colleague later published a paper in the Wilson Journal of Ornithology about the most extensive observations of the rare cardinal. Mr. Peer said that these observations increased their knowledge of gynandromorphs to the next level.
What To Do If You Spot A Half-Male, Half-Female Cardinal
Northern cardinals are one of the most stunning birds in North America. If you notice a rare half-male, half-female specimen in your backyard, at your favorite birding location, or somewhere in the wild, here’s what you should do.
- Share The Sighting: If you truly spot a rare cardinal bird, there are hundreds even thousands of birders out there who are probably looking for seeing the bird. You should photograph it and share it with others on various social media, like Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, etc.
- Report The Sighting: As an enthusiast birdwatcher, you should report the sighting. Confirm the ID with clear photos and let a local expert birder check the photos. Contact the American Birding Association or National Audubon Society for what to do next.
- Send the Sighting to Top Media: If you want to share the sighting worldwide, you will have to send the photos to top media, like BBC, New York Times, USA Today, National Geographic, etc. As an avid birder, you should let the world know the rare cardinal.
Now that you know a cardinal can be half-male, half-female, you should consider yourself fortunate if you notice such a cardinal in your backyard or anywhere in the wild. Spotting a dual-gendered cardinal is quite rare.
Once you notice a gynandromorph half male half female cardinal, let us see at least a picture of it. We would like to be among the fortunate. However, if you have ever watched such a cardinal, share the experience with us below in the comment section.
You Can Also Read:
- Male VS Female Cardinal [Read here]
- Where Do Cardinals Sleep At Night? [Read here]
- Are Cardinals Rare To See? [Read here]
- Are Cardinals Territorial Birds? [Read here]
- Are Cardinals Aggressive? [Read here]
- Can Cardinal Birds Be Pets? [Read here]
- Where Do Cardinals Build Their Nests? [Read here]
- Do Cardinals Use Birdhouses? [Read here]
- What Do Cardinals Eat? [Read here]
- How To Attract Cardinals? [Read here]
Hello David 🙂. My name is Shirley Caldwell…I photographed the Erie, Pennsylvania cardinal. Thanks for including my bird in your article. Just so you know, the image is flipped so that you have the male on the left side and the female side on the right. It should be the opposite way, especially when you were describing the Illinois bird in the paragraph below, describing their bird is being different from mine.
Thought you would like to know so you can edit.
Thanks again 🙂
I just changed the image and added a screenshot of your post on 27 January 2019 in the article. Hope you like it. Most Welcome @Shirley
We had a male cardinal and a male blue jay stayed over the winter surviving in a redl bush with red berries out side our dinning room doors
Are these birds able to reproduce?
No evidence has been found so far.